I want to give a gift as a secret admirer... what should I give?

Ok so this guy I like is super shy and so am I... his friends think he likes me too. So I figured I'd do something cute to get more of his attention... by putting together a little gift box of goodies and leavin it on his door step to make it look like it was mailed there. The only problem is I'm not quite sure what I should put in the box, I was thinking about putting his favorite candy in it, some type of things from Ohio state 'cause he loves them, maybe a mixed cd of his favorite music and the lyrics to a song that describes my feelings. But I don't know what else to put in it? Any suggestions?